I have a functionaity for reminders. I ahve configured as per documentation.But I see warning as (venv) geetadesai@MacBook-Pro rasa-calm % rasa data validate 2024-03-10 04:02:04 INFO rasa_plus.telemetry - Initialised global config file with Rasa Pro telemetry tracking set to True. 2024-03-10 04:02:06 INFO rasa.validator - Validating intents… /Users/geetadesai/rasa-calm/venv/lib/python3.10/site-packages/rasa/shared/utils/io.py:99: UserWarning: The intent ‘EXTERNAL_reminder_callback’ is not used in any story, rule or flow. Though my domain.yml has that entry responses: utter_time_for_medication: - text: “It’s time for your medication.” rules:
rule: Schedule medication reminder steps:
intent: schedule_medication
action: action_schedule_medication_reminder
rule: reminder callback steps: - intent: EXTERNAL_reminder_callback - action: action_notify_medication Git URL GitHub - geeta-m-desai/rasa-calm at new-branch2 Could you pelase provide some hints on this, I am stuck on this for 2 days.
(venv) geetadesai@MacBook-Pro rasa-calm % rasa --version Rasa Version : 3.7.8 Minimum Compatible Version: 3.7.0 Rasa SDK Version : 3.7.1 Python Version : 3.10.10 Operating System : macOS-14.3.1-x86_64-i386-64bit Python Path : /Users/geetadesai/rasa-calm/venv/bin/python3 Rasa Plus Version : 3.7.8
It always triggers intentlessPOlicy Your input → reminders
2024-03-10 04:48:11 INFO rasa.utils.log_utils - [info ] llm_command_generator.predict_commands.finished commands=[StartFlowCommand(flow=‘schedule_reminders’)] I will remind you in 5 seconds. What more can I assist you with? Your input → 2024-03-10 04:49:12 INFO rasa_plus.ml.intentless_policy - [info ] intentless_policy.prediction.completed predicted_action_name=utter_boolean_slot_rejection score=0.6538142578480671
Hi Geeta,
Reminders feature was initially designed to work with NLU Based assistants – there may be some issues while trying this with CALM assistants. I see that in your logs a flow schedule_reminders and the action_notify_medication run properly. Is the only issue the visible warning?
Instead of using a rule (which do not work in CALM assistants), you can add an intent trigger to your flows.
Thanks for repsondng. No issue is not only with warning. My External_Revert reminder intent is never recognized . See below for logs
2024-04-02 18:16:46 DEBUG rasa_sdk.executor - Received request to run ‘action_schedule_medication_reminder’
reminder ===> {‘event’: ‘reminder’, ‘timestamp’: 1712062006.452625, ‘intent’: ‘EXTERNAL_revert’, ‘entities’: None, ‘date_time’: ‘2024-04-02T18:16:56.452605+05:30’, ‘name’: ‘medication_reminder’, ‘kill_on_user_msg’: False}
2024-04-02 18:16:46 DEBUG rasa_sdk.executor - Finished running ‘action_schedule_medication_reminder’
Conversation:
USER: reminder
AI: I will remind you in 5 seconds.
AI: Is there anything else you need assistance with?
USER: EXTERNAL: EXTERNAL_revert
Summary: summarization=The user requested a reminder from the AI, which was set for 5 seconds. The AI then asked if there was anything else the user needed assistance with.
2024-04-02 18:17:01 DEBUG rasa_plus.ml.contextual_response_rephraser - [debug ] nlg.rephrase.prompt prompt=The following is a conversation with
I have use DIETCLASSIFIER and NLUCommandAdapter,LLMCommandGenerator
And set up prooer flows
schedule_reminders:
nlu_trigger:
- intent: schedule_medication
confidence_threshold: 0.2 # optional
name: schedule_medication
description: reminder
steps:
- action: action_schedule_medication_reminder
EXTERNAL_revert:
nlu_trigger:
- intent: EXTERNAL_revert
confidence_threshold: 0.2 # optional
name: EXTERNAL_revert
description: EXTERNAL_revert
steps:
- action: action_notify_medication
As earlier John had relied back saying with CALM reminders was never designed and we need to use nlu.
Infact I have tried multiple things on this in alst few days , I could not get it working. Any help is highly appreciated.
I haven’t noticed the other thread, my apologies! What John has said is true, reminders were never designed to work with CALM. For now the old NLU style is the way to go, we will update you if there is a better way to use reminders
I solved this problem by invoking callback channel with reminder event programtiaclly from custom action i.e my action of schedule_reminders. Can this approach bring any challanges later?
Glad to hear you got it working! Your method of programmatically invoking a callback channel with a reminder event through a custom action like schedule_reminders is quite intriguing. Did you develop this using flows or rules? While your approach seems efficient, it’s valuable to consider any potential challenges, particularly in terms of error handling and scalability for the custom action. It would be incredibly helpful for the community if you could share more details about your implementation. Maybe, would you be willing to share the code? This could allow others to learn from your approach and possibly suggest enhancements or alternatives.
It was not possible to send the reminder message on socket channel with callback handler , faced many issues Hence I took traditional approach of saving reminders in db and a scheduler to send reminders
