Contradicting rules, when add two forms in a rule

Rasa Open Source
1

Hi there!

I have a bot with single intents and it works fine, now I am required to make accept multiple intents. When I tried to just combine the rules for two intents together, I got an error of contradicting rules.

InvalidRule: 
Contradicting rules or stories found 🚨

- the prediction of the action 'simple_info_form' in rule 'crop info and price' is contradicting with rule(s) 'handling active loops and forms - simple_crop_form - action_listen' which predicted action 'action_listen'.
Please update your stories and rules so that they don't contradict each other.

This is my rules.yml file:

##############################################################3
  - rule: Get the crop info
    steps:
      - intent: crop_info_request
      - action: action_detect_crop_type
      - action: action_detect_info_type
      - action: simple_info_form
      - active_loop: simple_info_form

  - rule: Submit crop info Form
    condition:
      - active_loop: simple_info_form
    steps:
      - action: simple_info_form
      - active_loop: null
      - slot_was_set:
          - requested_slot: null
      - action: action_get_crop_info
  ##############################################################3
  - rule: ask for crop price
    steps:
      - intent: crop_prices_request
      - action: action_detect_crop_type
      - action: simple_crop_form
      - active_loop: simple_crop_form

  - rule: Submit crop price Form
    condition:
      - active_loop: simple_crop_form
    steps:
      - action: simple_crop_form
      - active_loop: null
      - slot_was_set:
          - requested_slot: null
      - action: action_get_crop_price
  ##############################################################3
  - rule: crop info and price
    steps:
      - intent: crop_info_request+crop_prices_request
      - action: action_detect_crop_type
      - action: action_detect_info_type
      - action: simple_crop_form
      - active_loop: simple_crop_form
      - action: simple_info_form
      - active_loop: simple_info_form
2

Hi @BodaSadalla98 , It seems you are trying to do intent composition i.e. compose two intents. Have you considered creating stories instead of rules. Look at best practice - Writing Conversation Data You could use checkpoint also if the story block is going to be repeated.

3

Hello @mindseye, thanks for answering me. Basically, I need to have a multi-intent classification, so in my case: I have two rules, everyone opens and submits a form, and I try to combine them in a new rule, that should open the two forms consecutively. Here, is where I get the rule contradiction error. Another solution would be to combine the two forms in one new form, but that would be a pain.